Q-Review – recording and publishing service

Q-Review Logo

Q-Review is a service for the recording and distribution of teaching activity. The project aims to encourage innovative and flexible teaching methods, and allows lecturers to retain full control over their recordings. The project is now included in KPI’s (key performance indicators) for top-level college plans and is a key strand of activity of the IT Strategy Implementation Programme.

The underlying software used for Q-Review is the Echo360 system.

To learn about the use of the Q-review service, visit our support pages.

Click on a question to see the answer.

What is the project’s history and code of practice? – click to expand/contract
The project began in March 2006 and was running at a low-level until Spring 2009 when new installations were funded as part of the Teaching Room Refurbishment Project. 

This tied in with requests from academics to broaden the availability of the system. We responded to that need by making a portable installation (on a tablet PC) available for short term loans. As part of the Teaching Room Refurbishment project, new systems were installed into three centrally bookable theatres. This has been expanded again to include the range of options described above.

There has been a technical, legal and educational skills need for this project team. ELU can, and has, been providing the educational input and has endeavoured to fill the skills-gap for both technical and legal team members. IT Services, AV and Room Bookings have all contributed to the project over the last year and now all four groups are represented on the project team.

The code of practice is available here – Q-review code of practice.pdf

How does it work? – click to expand/contract
Recordings in lecture rooms (with the required equipment installed) can be scheduled, and are automatically made available in your Blackboard course area, as an RSS feed for iTunes, or as a link for download to, for example, mobile devices. This can be automated to record a complete schedule for up to a year in advance.

You also have the option to record presentations using a desktop or laptop computer.

In both cases this will record the audio, video and capture your presentation (in suitably equiped lecture theatres this may include your slides, visualiser materials, interactive whiteboard or on-screen annotations).

Following a completed recording you will receive an email with a link to an audio mp3, a video mp4 – both for mobile devices, and a link to an ‘echo’ (i.e. recording).

Why make use of the Q-review service? – click to expand/contract
“Professor X recorded all his lectures and made them available for everyone to listen to… this was really useful and I was able to make sure I had written down important points from the… lectures. I think it was one of the reasons why I obtained a first for that module”.

In focus groups, surveys and interviews at QMUL both students and staff who have made use of the system have found it valuable to teaching and learning.
Of the teaching staff who have used Q-Review, 100% would recommend the service to others, with one user stating “Outstanding facility, outstandingly well supported”. Another lecturer commented that “Any form of multi-media that facilitates passing of information from teacher to student is a valuable tool both in learning and teaching” and that “I was quite nervous about doing this at first. Some of my lectures are quite complicated, and I was worried about mistakes that I may make, and also about student attendance. But so far, so good! Students thank me for participating so it is obviously very popular with them.”

For more insights from teaching staff at QMUL you can find case studies and interviews here: http://www.learninginstitute.qmul.ac.uk/elearning/support/qreview/qmul-case-studies/

Students have been overwhelmingly positive in their support of the system.
When asked “do you think that the recording of lectures are helpful to your studies?”, 95% said yes, and were very forthcoming with comments. There were near 500 additional free-text comments on this question which revealed a reasoned and critical awareness of the surrounding issues.

You can read a summary of results from our 2011 survey here: http://www.learninginstitute.qmul.ac.uk/elearning/news-and-events/podcasting-survey-student/

One student summarised the benefits as:

“(a) Can go back and listen to them more than once if you dont understand a point, (b) can listen to them in your own time. (c) can make more thorough notes from them by pausing and playing them. (d) can catch up on any missed lectures. (e) helps to refresh memory during exam time”. Another student commented “I find it difficult to absorb the entire lecture whilst sat taking notes. The recorded lectures have been invaluable to my current high grades”

When used as a simple automated system with no extra workload for teaching staff, it can:

  • Aid in effective revision by learners
  • Allow note-checking after the lecture
  • Promote better use of text books
  • Diminish the assumed need for PowerPoint to be posted on the VLE
  • Help Non-native English languages speakers
  • Help disabled and dyslexic students

For more innovative uses we can suggest scenarios like:

Pre-recording lectures and using the face-to-face time for knowledge building activities. One student suggests that “The podcast version of a lecture should be used to disseminate the basic information – the physical lecture would provide an opportunity to spend more time dealing with more complex parts of the podcast. ”

Lectures can be supported by supplementary materials. For example, one academic uses the software on his own laptop and gives ten minutes of generic feedback recorded at home once a week

You can edit out bite-size ‘chunks’ where a specific concept was covered as part of a full lecture.

What do students at Queen Mary think of this service? – click to expand/contract
We have been running surveys and focus groups with QMUL students. The details of which are freely available upon request. In summary here is some feedback from QM Students:  

“This is really helpful, thank you for taking the time”

“As someone who learns quicker when watching something, as opposed to just reading about it, I found your video very very helpful”

“The teaching method provided online was fantastic!! If only other lecturers would do it too!”

“That it can be played again and again (which) aids in following complicated exercises by repeating it as much as we need”

“I have been thinking to myself all year that recorded lectures would have been useful and why does QM not have them. I support them fully, but not as a substitute for lectures”

“Come join the rest of the world in the 21st century”

How do I make use of this service? – click to expand/contract
To learn about the use of the Q-review service, vist our support pages here.


Relevant Articles

Articles written by the e-Learning Unit about the Q-review service are listed below.
DateTitle Category Tags
January 25, 2012 “Recording lectures does not make a scrap of difference to attendance”

Last year Professor Hinson used the Q-Review lecture capture service for the first time to record her live lectures in the Drapers and Perrin Lecture Theatres. In this interview, Professor Hinson shares her experience of getting her lectures recorded and offers tips of what she has found works best for her when doing so.

Case studies
January 20, 2012 Part 2 – Editing a Q-Review Recording

This is part 2 of an interview with Mike Noon. Mike explains that students already record using their own devices, so he wanted to give them a better quality recording.

By using Q-Review, Mike is able to edit the recording to remove parts that he is not happy with, before distributing to students via his course on the Virtual Learning Environment.

Case studies
January 9, 2012 Part 1 – Why everyone should give Q-Review a try

This is part 1 of an interview with Mike Noon on his experience of recording live lectures using the Q-Review lecture capture system.

Mike feels everyone should give Q-Review a try. Apart from its ease of use, Mike explained that he felt Q-Review gave students extra support, and allowed him to give a better quality lecture to his students.

Case studies , ,
August 22, 2011 Q-Review is expanding

Q-Review, the lecture recording service at QMUL, is expanding. More rooms and free licenses for any staff member to install it onto your laptops. Find out where we’re installing it next and get in touch if you’d like to try it out.

Blog posts , ,
May 17, 2011 Podcasting at QM – the Student Perspective

“I find it difficult to absorb the entire lecture whilst sat taking notes. The recorded lectures have been invaluable to my current high grades.” – Student response, Q-Review Survey   We recently ran a survey on podcasting lectures at QM, seeking the views of staff and students on this technology.  We received 614 responses from [...]

News and Events , ,
May 16, 2011 QM Podcasting Survey Results

Dr. Katherine Fleming, from the school of English and Drama, was the lucky winner of a Kindle which was a prize draw for those who completed our Podcasting Lectures at QM Survey. The survey attracted 83 staff and 614 student respondents who shared their views on the technology.

News and Events
Reviews
, ,
March 16, 2011 Angie Raymond shares her Q-Review experience

Angie Raymond, from the Centre for Commercial Law Studies, gives tips on recording lectures using Q-Review Personal Capture. She also talks about student attendance…

Case studies
Reviews
, ,
March 10, 2011 How to edit a Q-Review recording

It is easy to edit recordings using the Q-Review online Presentation Editor. You can edit your recording yourself from any computer with internet access. The Q-Review Presentation Editor offers a user-friendly interface and allows you to trim sections of the recording that you want removed…

How-to guidance , , ,
February 3, 2011 Take part in our survey and win a Kindle!

“Podcasting lectures at QM… seeking staff and student views”

The E-Learning Unit is currently surveying staff and students to find out their views on podcasting lectures at QM. Tell us what you think and you could win a Kindle!

News and Events , , ,
November 5, 2010 Law lecturer turns his lecture material into podcasts

Mr. Bishop felt conscious over the years that too much of his class time was being spent giving basic content, leaving little time to explain the material to his students. So he decided to turn this basic content into podcasts which his students could listen to before class, take necessary notes, and then he could [...]

Case studies
Reviews
,